Best Board Game Subscription Box Games for Game Night

Board Game Subscription Box

As board gamers, we are always looking for new ways to spice up our game nights. We have found tons of enjoyment in receiving monthly board game subscription boxes that we can unbox and play with our friends or family each month. From escape rooms to solving mysteries to unique board games, these subscription boxes have it all! This is why we decided to put together a list of the best board game subscription boxes for game night! We love opening our board game subscription box during our game nights and we are sure you will too!

As you know, we love the Hunt A Killer subscription box game that we receive every month. It gives us the opportunity to get together with our friends each month to unbox and solve an ongoing mystery. Hunt A Killer is one of our favorite board game subscription box games to play (more on this later). The downside to Hunt A Killer is that they do not have a huge variety of boxes and only really focus on murder mysteries (hence the name Hunt A Killer).

Therefore, we have found that Cratejoy is another awesome subscription box service that offers a variety of ‘board games in a box’ from various companies that you can receive and play in the comfort of your own home! We will go over both Cratejoy subscription boxes and Hunt A Killer boxes in this article!

While on a monthly board game subscription, you receive tightly packed boxes full of goodies such as geeky physical objects, mysteries to solve, puzzles to solve, new board games to play, and ‘rooms’ to escape. The best part is that they are delivered right to your door each month and ready to unpack the moment you receive them!

Best Board Game Subscription Box Games for Game Night

If you are looking to add more variety into your game night, look no further! Here is our list of the best board game subscription boxes for game night! Remember, that these are monthly board game subscription boxes, meaning that once you subscribe, you receive a new box each month (or in some cases, every two months).

You can always cancel your subscription or hop on a new one. The best part is that there are tons of boxes to choose from, so feel free to try a few out. You may find one that you want to stay subscribed to and receive a different box full of awesome content each month.

Now onto our list to help you find the best board game subscription box from Cratejoy!

1. UnboxBoardom – Board Game Subscription Box

Board Game Subscription Box

This monthly board game subscription box is a MUST HAVE for all board game lovers! If you want to dip your feet into the idea of subscription box gaming, then this is the perfect box to start with. The UnboxBoardom Subscription boxincludes everything from strategic board games, tabletop card games, and fun party games.

In simple terms, UnboxBoardom is a subscription board game service, where you pay a monthly fee to receive new board games. The best part is that you never have to worry about receiving a game that you already have because they allow you to choose which board game you would like to receive before your box ships.

You have the opportunity to choose your favorite game from 3 featured options or opt to be surprised for which games arrive in your box. Subscriptions start at $29.99 a month and here are the different options you can choose from:

  • Board Game Beginner: 1 new game every 3 months (4 a year)
  • Casual Gamer: 1 new game every 2 months
  • Gaming Guru: 1 new game every month

The awesome thing about this box is that you have the option to preview and choose from three selections as to which new game you would like to receive. So if you are an avid board gamer, you never have to worry about getting a game you already have! These games are usually unique and “hot on the market” board games.

The slogan for this service is that UnboxBoardom delivers the “hottest, brand-new board games delivered right to your door to keep.” We believe that UnboxBoardom delivers on their promises and it is a great way to receive new board games that we do not already have in our collection.

We are always trying to stay on top of the latest trends for new board games, but sometimes there are games that we do not even know about! That is why having a subscription to UnboxBoardom is great for us, as we can receive new board games each month and grow our collection.

A bonus to hopping on board (see what we did there) this subscription box service is the team at Cratejoy donates a game to kids who can’t afford their own for every 10 new subscribers that sign up! How awesome is that?!

We have a lot to say about this great board game subscription box, so be sure to read our full UnboxBoardom Review.

UnboxBoardom is definitely worth a try if you are an avid board gamer looking to experience fresh, new games and grow your board game collection. We always love when we see an UnboxBoardom box on our doorstep!

Start Your UnboxBoardom Subscription Today by Clicking Here >>

2. Escape the Crate – Escape Room Subscription Box

Escape the crate subscription box

If you love escape rooms and are missing being able to do an escape room due to the coronavirus pandemic, then this box is for you! Escape the Crate is a bi-monthly “Escape Room” subscription box full of puzzles and mysteries to solve. We love going to escape rooms, but what we love even more is being able to do an escape room in the comfort of our own home!

Being able to work together to solve puzzles and mysteries is something we enjoy doing with friends and/or family. We have found that the ‘Escape the Crate’ subscription box is perfect for this! The box is packed with ciphers, letters, sleuthing tools, puzzles, and more that will make for a great game night with over an hours worth of content. You receive a different escape room box every two months so that each adventure is unique and different.

The best part about this ‘Escape Room in a box’ is that you can play with a large group of people, making it perfect for game night. We have played with up to 6 people comfortably, as we were able to pass around clues, with each person working on a different puzzle or riddle. Putting the pieces together and unlocking the next steps is the best part of escape rooms and this box showcases that very well.

Unlock other subscription boxes, each box is unique to itself and you do not have to wait around for the next box to continue the mystery. If you are more of a “one and done” person and like to move on to new and exciting adventures each month, then this box is definitely for you.

The Escape the Crate box is both challenging and fun! You will never feel like it was ‘too easy’ and if you ever do get stuck on something, there are clues to help along the way. This subscription box is perfect for game night, date night, or any other occasion with friends or family.

Start Your Escape the Crate Subscription Today by Clicking Here >>

3. Deadbolt Mystery Society

Deadbolt Mystery Society Subscription Box

If you are a fan of mysteries and true crime, then this subscription box is a must have! We know so many friends and family members who love true crime tv shows and podcasts, and we have introduced them to this box. With the Deadbolt Mystery Society subscription box, you are thrown into the action where you must work to solve a new and exciting mystery each month.

Each monthly box brings a suspenseful stand-alone mystery, complete with intriguing characters and storylines, and packed with plenty of challenging puzzles, codes, trivia, and clues. Designed for between 4-6 players, keep the whole team on their toes as everyone works together to unravel the mystery.

If you are a fan of the Hunt A Killer murder mystery subscription box, but do not want to wait 6 months to solve one mystery, then you should definitely subscribe to this box as each box is it’s own stand-alone case to solve. This is one of the reasons we love this box, as it’s one and done, solve the mystery and close the case!

We have found that the Deadbolt Mystery Society boxes from Cratejoy are perfectly put together and our gameplay lasted for hours of fun, without anyone in our group getting bored or disinterested. It makes for a perfect game night or date night activity for all.

As a true crime junkie myself, I have loved every detailed aspect of this box and look forward to receiving my board game subscription box of Deadbolt Mystery Society each month.

Some things we love about this board game subscription box for game night is that it is cooperative and can be played comfortably with a group up to 6 people. Also, it is of moderate difficulty (not too hard, not too easy) and contains quality components (great writing, professionally planned out, high quality printing, etc.). Lastly, this subscription box has an awesome online community, with others playing through the box and there to help you if you need it.

It’s time to solve a crime. Start Your Deadbolt Mystery Society Subscription Today by Clicking Here >>

4. Finders Seekers Mysteries

Finders Seekers Mysteries

Step up your game night and solve this awesome mystery in a box! Bringing between 2-4 hours of gameplay fun, Finders Seekers Mysteries offers a one-of-a-kind game night experience by immersing players into a new city and culture where they will encounter a mystery that’s waiting to be solved.

This subscription box is definitely one of our favorites as we are able to explore a new city and culture every month. The contents of the box consists of solving puzzles and deciphering codes with a fun escape room challenge every month!

Since traveling is very limited right now, this monthly board game subscription allows us to still experience the outside world of cities full of culture and life, something we have been missing a lot recently.

The Finders Seekers Mysteries subscription box is great for game and mystery fans, puzzle solvers, and travel enthusiasts! It is family-friendly and includes everything you need for a fun game night at home.

Finders Seekers Mysteries is a really fun activity that definitely is not too easy nor too difficult. The items inside the box are always really good quality and make great keepsakes.

Start your Finders Seekers Mysteries Subscription Today by Clicking Here >>

5. The Conundrum Box

The Conundrum Subscription Box

The Conundrum Subscription Box is a newer box from Cratejoy that has definitely made it’s way on to our list of our favorite board game subscription boxes for game night.

Get a monthly adventure shipped right to your door! Part escape room, part choose-your-own adventure, wind your way through fun and exciting narratives by solving puzzles with your family and friends.

With this subscription box service, immerse yourself in different story environments through music, food, history, fiction, and drink recommendations. Contents within the box include physical objects to manipulate and solve, puzzles, ciphers, hints, stories, and plenty of material to contemplate. Additional resources include in-theme recipes and drink cards, suggested playlists, and other goodies.

Everything you need for a perfect game night with friends or family is included within this box. This is why we love it so much!

Each monthly box includes unique storylines that can continue from box to box, but every box has a definite and satisfying ending. You will meet a host of characters from literature and history that will help guide you through your adventure.

Some subscription boxes provide a short gameplay experience, but each Conundrum box has 1.5 – 3 hours of unique gameplay centered around fun themes and immersive puzzles. We have found that not only are these games well-constructed and clever, there are cocktail recipes and playlists included for each pack! This was right up our alley!

Our group deems this box as fun, interactive and challenging. Something we love to do is solve puzzles and put our mind to use. This subscription box allows us to do just that, as well as providing the opportunity to go on adventures around the world and find out the answer to unsolved mysteries.

Start your Conundrum Box Subscription Today by Clicking Here >>

6. Hunt A Killer

Murder Mystery Subscription Box

Hunt A Killer is a murder mystery subscription box game where your role is to become a detective and work to solve a crime. Specifically, the crime involves a murder with many different unique suspects. Once you subscribe, you are in a Hunt A Killer ‘season’ and each season lasts 6 months.

This board game subscription box is different than the other monthly game boxes listed above as it is an ongoing mystery that takes place over several boxes.

You don’t have to be a ‘murder mystery junkie’ to perk up and be pumped about this idea of a ‘murder mystery subscription box.’ If you know someone who likes playing games where they can be fully immersed in the content and experience, then this may be the right fit  for them.

With the Hunt A Killer subscription, you receive a box once a month for the duration of your season. Each box is full of unique objects; including paper documents, physical items, puzzles, and clues. It is your job to decipher the clues and lead the investigation that will carry on over to the next month. Complete the full sixth month investigation and find out if you were successfully able to Hunt A Killer.

We have played through many of the Hunt A Killer subscription boxes, and have had such a great experience living through every chilling tale. Make sure to read our in depth Hunt A Killer Review.

Click here to start your Hunt A Killer Subscription today >>

7. Hunt A Killer Horror: Blair Witch

Hunt A Killer Horror Blair Witch Review

The team at Hunt A Killer are passionate about telling stories that are full of mystery in a unique and memorable way. They do this by immersing their players into the story by delivering monthly subscription boxes full of physical items, documents, puzzles, sound recording, digital files, and more.

Their newest experience is called the Hunt A Killer Blair Witch game that takes place over the course of six “episodes,” or boxes, in the span of six months. Each month, you receive a new box with new clues, documents, and physical items that will lead you further down the path of solving the mystery of a missing person. There are also options to buy in bulk to save some money, which I will discuss later in this review.

This Blair Witch inspired horror mystery game captures the tale of the original 1999 Lionsgate film, “The Blair Witch Project,” where a new tale unfolds of a woman’s son going missing under mysterious circumstances.

As kids, we watched three filmmakers explore the dark Black Hills Forest as they were overcome by dark forces and the so-called “Blair Witch.” Now we are brought back in and are enlisted to help with a new tale that has been cursed by the Blair Witch.

In this new horror game by Hunt A Killer, players will experience the supernatural forces of the Blair Witch and will receive a new box of clues, documents and ciphers each month that will bring them closer to the truth.

We were so excited to receive our first box and dive into this horror mystery. To learn more, be sure to read our full Hunt A Killer Blair Witch Review.

If you are like us and have seen the “Blair Witch Project” film plenty of times, then you know that the mystery of the Blair Witch is maybe one of the creepiest stories ever told.

Click here to start your Hunt A Killer Horror: Blair Witch subscription box today >>

Monthly Board Game Subscription Box Games

I hope you enjoyed this article on our favorite monthly board game subscription boxes. Feel free to use the links above to start your journey today and begin unboxing your monthly “board game in a box.”

The Hunt A Killer boxes and the new Hunt A Killer Horror boxes are so much fun to play and we love receiving our new boxes each month. Hunt A Killer does have a lot of other boxes and options on their website, so be sure to take a look!

As we receive and subscribe to more boxes from Cratejoy, we will be sure to add to this list. But feel free to browse the Cratejoy site to maybe find some hidden gems that we haven’t been able to play yet!

Keep in mind, Cratejoy does have a bunch of other subscription boxes that may peek your interest. Feel free to take a look around Cratejoy, you may just find something you never knew would enhance your lifestyle, whether it’s playing board games or doing something else you enjoy!

If you have any questions or suggestions on the best board game subscription box games, please leave a comment below!


Hillary is a 28 year old board game enthusiast from New York who specializes in hosting game nights.

Recent Posts